ARTICULO ORIGINAL
REVISTA DE LA FACULTAD DE MEDICINA HUMANA 2021 - Universidad Ricardo Palma
1Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, Perú.
aEstudiante de pregrado de Medicina
bDoctor en Medicina.
ABSTRACT
Introduction:The changes in styles life predisposes university students to face constant stressful situations and to modify their eating habits and physical activity, with possible alterations in the body mass index. Objective: To evaluate the relationship between body mass index and stress, physical activity and eating habits in medical students. Methods: Cross-sectional descriptive observational study. 306 medical students participated from first to sixth year: 153 with normal weight, 121 with overweight and 32 with obesity, average age 22 years. The body mass index was considered and the questionnaires were applied: Global Perception of Stress Scale for University Students (Adapted in Peruvian university students), International Physical Activity Questionnaire and the modified Reyes Food Frequency Questionnaire, using Google software Forms. Results: The proportion of normal weight was 50%, overweight 39,5% and obese 10,5%. According to eating habits, people with body mass index significantly increased their consumption of soft drinks (p = 0,030), meat (p = 0,017) and alcohol (p = 0,005), more frequent breakfast (p = 0,037) and less consumption of legumes (p = 0,049). The levels of distress were lower in the obese (p = 0,055); there was no significant difference in physical activity. Conclusions: The elevation of the body mass index in medical students was associated with inadequate eating habits. Low levels of distress and physical activity were more frequent in obese people, although without significant difference.
Keywords:Body Mass Index,Life Stress,Food Habits, Physical activity (fuente: MeSH NLM).
RESUMEN
Introducción: Los cambios en los estilos de vida predisponen a los estudiantes universitarios a enfrentar constantes situaciones de estrés y a modicar sus hábitos alimenticios y actividad física, con posibles alteraciones en el índice de masa corporal (IMC). Objetivo: Evaluar la relación que existe entre el IMC con el estrés, actividad física y hábitos alimenticiosenestudiantesdemedicina.Métodos:Estudioobservacionaldescriptivotransversal.Muestra conformada por 306 estudiantes de medicina de primero a sexto año: 153 con normopeso, 121 con sobrepeso y 32 con obesidad, edad promedio 22 años. Se consideró el IMC y se aplicaron los cuestionarios: (EPGE) para Universitarios (en estudiantes universitarios peruanos), Cuestionario Internacional de Actividad Física (CIAF) y el Cuestionario de Frecuencia de alimentos modicada de Reyes (CFAMR) , mediante el software de Google Forms. Resultados: La proporción de normopeso fue 50 %, sobrepeso 39,5 % y obesos 10,5 %. Según los hábitos alimenticios, las personas con IMC aumentado tuvieron signicativamente mayor consumo de bebidas gaseosas (p=0,030), carne (p=0,017) y alcohol (p=0,005), mayor frecuencia de desayuno (p=0,037) y menor consumo de legumbres (p=0,049). Los niveles de distrés fueron menores en los obesos (p=0,055); no hubo diferencia signicativa en la actividad física. Conclusiones: La elevación del (IMC) en estudiantes de medicina se asoció a hábitos alimenticios inadecuados. Los niveles bajos de distrés y de actividad física fueron más frecuentes en obesos, aunque sin diferencia signicativa.
Palabras Clave: Índice de Masa Corporal, Estrés, Hábitos Alimenticios, Actividad Física (fuente: DeCS BIREME).
INTRODUCTION
The beginning of university life is a critical stage for
young people since changes in learning methods and
the search for better academic results generate
emotional conicts that can affect the feeling of hunger,
appetite, and satiety, inuencing their state
nutritional(1) . Indeed, anthropometric alterations occur
that can be reected in an increased or decreased body
mass index (BMI).
Until 2016, according to the World Health Organization
(WHO), 1.9 billion adults were overweight or obesed(2) ,
the latter constituting an increasing health problem in
Peru(3) , where approximately 60.2% of the population
adult is overweight(4) . Among its consequences is the
development of non-communicable diseases (NCDs)
such as diabetes mellitus, arterial hypertension,
metabolic syndrome, and polycystic ovary(3) .
On the other hand, stress, a process in which
physiological, emotional, and behavioral responses are
generated from a stimulus(5) , causes manifestations of a
cardiac nature, muscle tension, alterations in breathing
and digestive problems; in addition to impaired
performance, sleep disorders, increased or decreased
appetite, and anxiety(6) .
According to the WHO, physical activity (PA) refers to
any body movement tha t require s energy
consumption(7) . FA prevents the appearance of
overweight, obesity, and ENT, it also has advantages in
the psychological and cognitive states. However,
physical inactivity constitutes an important risk factor
for mortality worldwide(8) .
A sedentary lifestyle predisposes you to weight gain. In
this regard, an association has been found between the
former, nutritional status and moderate academic
performance(9) ; as well as a high frequency of
overweight and obesity in medical students(10) . In these
university students, the prevalence of a sedentary
lifestyle is reported to be 46% in the US, 50% in
Colombia, 70% in Chile, and 79% in Peru(11,12) .
The disadvantages to performing PA, the low
motivation to exercise, the low or no vegetable intake, and the tendency to consume fast food, energy drinks,
and soft drinks as substitutes for breakfast or lunch,
despite the knowledge of healthy eating patterns(13,14) ; In
addition to increasing academic stress, they increase
the risk to your health. Faced with such a problem, the
present study evaluated the relationship between BMI,
stress, physical activity, and eating habits in medical
students.
METHODS
Design and study area
A cross-sectional descriptive observational study was developed, carried out with medical students from the National University of Trujillo (UNT) who attended the University Welfare Service (SBU) in the 2020 period.
Population And Sample
The population consisted of 619 students in grades one through six. A convenience sampling was carried out, obtaining a sample of 306 students (153 normal weight, 121 overweight, 32 obesity). The inclusion criteria were: medical students enrolled in the 2020 period, whose medical records presented complete data on BMI; the exclusion criteria were: students with a disease that affects the BMI, with physical disabilities, pregnant women.
Variables and instruments
The qualitative variables were evaluated: nutritional
status, physical activity, stress, and eating habits. The
nutritional status was determined from the BMI and the
sample was classied as normal weight, overweight,
and obesity. Physical activity was categorized as low,
moderate, and high, using the International Physical
Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ)(15) . Stress was classied
into distress and eustress using the Global Stress
Perception Scale for University Students (Adapted and
validated in Peruvian university students by Guzmán-
Yacaman)(16) . Eating habits were recorded through the
modied ReyesFood Frequency Questionnaire(17) .
Access was obtained to the medical records of the
students treated at the Servicio de Bienestar
Universitario (SBU) in the period December 2019 -
March 2020. The weight and height data, previously
taken by SBU staff, were reviewed using a scale Seca
Model 700 mechanical brand, with a sensitivity of 50
grams; and height rod Seca 220, properly calibrated.
Procedures
From the information obtained from the clinical records
belonging to the SBU, the BMI was calculated and the
students were classied in the categories described,
through a data collection sheet.
Subsequently, to ll out the questionnaires, a virtual call
was made among the students who presented
complete data in the SBU. Those who agreed to
participate in the study were asked to ll out informed
consent and a questionnaire to rule out possible
chronic diseases that could distort weight or height or
both at the same time. It was veried that the students
meet the inclusion and exclusion criteria.
One week prior to the start of the virtual classes, the
study participants were applied, through Google
Forms, the referred questionnaires to evaluate the
variables physical activity, stress, and eating habits.
Statistical Analysis
The information was recorded and ordered using the Microsoft Excel 2016 program. The results of the anthropometric measures, stress, physical activity, and eating habits of the sample were organized in tables and prevalence gures. The Chi-square test (X was applied to evaluate the statistical association of categorical variables, using a signicance level of 0.05 to determine whether or not there was a relationship between the study variables; the condence level was 95%.
Ethical Aspects
The project was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine of the National University of Trujillo. The International Ethical Guidelines for Health-related Research with Human Beings developed by the Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences (CIOMS) in collaboration with WHO for the collection, storage, and use of data in research related to health, complying with the coding, condentiality, and anonymity of the participants(18) . The provisions of the Code of Ethics of the Medical College of Peru complied with(19) .
RESULTS
The sample consisted of 306 rst to sixth-year medical students: 195 men (63.7%) and 111 women (36.3%). There were 153 students with normal weight (50%), 121 with overweight (39.5%), and 32 with obesity (10.5%). The average age was 21.95 years (Table 1).
Table 1. Studied population of medical students
Number |
Average age of the total |
BMI |
Total |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year |
Men |
Women |
Normal |
Overweight |
Obesity |
||
Primero |
16 |
18 |
19,91 ± 1,83 |
17 |
15 |
2 |
34 |
Segundo |
50 |
28 |
20,55 ± 1,51 |
39 |
29 |
10 |
78 |
Tercero |
41 |
19 |
21,53 ± 1,81 |
30 |
25 |
5 |
60 |
Cuarto |
36 |
14 |
22,98 ± 2,27 |
25 |
21 |
4 |
50 |
Quinto |
27 |
15 |
23,05 ± 1,61 |
21 |
16 |
5 |
42 |
Sexto |
25 |
17 |
24,45 ± 1,19 |
21 |
15 |
6 |
42 |
Total |
195 |
111 |
21,95 ± 2,27 |
153 |
121 |
32 |
306 |
Table 2. Eating habits according to the BMI of medical students
Frequency |
Normal weight (%) |
Overweight (%) |
Obesity (%) |
Total (%) |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Soft drinks |
Never / almost never |
82,89 |
73,77 |
68,75 |
77,78 |
Occasional |
15,14 |
15,57 |
21,88 |
16,01 |
|
Frequent |
1,97 |
10,66 |
9,38 |
6,21 |
|
Legumes |
Never /almost Never |
7,19 |
7,44 |
9,38 |
7,52 |
Ocasional |
16,34 |
20,66 |
18,75 |
18,30 |
|
Frequent |
76,47 |
71,90 |
71,87 |
74,18 |
|
Legumes |
Never / almost never |
1,31 |
6,61 |
0,00 |
3,27 |
Ocasional |
19,61 |
23,14 |
31,25 |
22,22 |
|
Frequent |
79,08 |
70,25 |
68,75 |
74,51 |
|
Carnes |
Never /almost never |
1,31 |
7,44 |
0,00 |
3,59 |
Ocasional |
10,46 |
16,53 |
9,38 |
12,75 |
|
Common |
88,23 |
76,03 |
90,62 |
83,66 |
|
Alcohol |
Never /almost never |
86,77 |
86,78 |
65,62 |
84,97 |
Ocasional |
10,46 |
6,61 |
25,00 |
10,46 |
|
Frequent |
1,96 |
6,61 |
9,38 |
4,57 |
Regarding the frequency of eating habits in students
according to BMI, Table 2 a signicant difference was
found in the consumption of soft drinks (p = 0.030),
legumes (p = 0.049), meat (p = 0.017) and alcohol (p =
0.005). People with increased BMI reported higher
consumption of soft drinks, meat and alcohol, while lower intake of legumes. In relation to the foods of the
categories pastry, sweets, fruits, and fast food, no
signicant association was found.
In addition, it was observed that the frequency of
breakfast had a signicant difference in relation to BMI
(p = 0.037) (Table 3).
Table 3. Frequency of breakfast according to BMI in medical students
Normal weight (%) | Overweight (%) | Obesity (%) | Total (%) | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Daily | 98,69 | 92,56 | 93,75 | 95,75 |
Occasional | 1,31 | 7,44 | 6,25 | 4,25 |
100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
finding a lower frequency of its occasional have a signicant difference. consumption in students with normal weight (1.31%) when compared with those who were overweight (7.44%) and obesity (6.25%). The other variables studied (fasting, mid-morning, lunch, snack, and dinner) did not have a signicant difference. When evaluating the relationship between stress and BMI, it was observed that the levels of distress presented an association close to signicance (p = 0.055); being, such levels, lower in students with obesity (Figure 1).
Regarding the PA of the participants according to BMI, no signicant difference was found. Low physical activity was 36.6% in students with normal BMI, 42.2% in overweight students, and 43.9% in obese students (Table 4).
Table 4. Level of physical activity according to BMI in medical student
Level |
Normal weight (%) |
Overweight (%) |
Obesity (%) |
Total (%) |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Low |
36,60 |
42,15 |
43,75 |
39,54 |
|
Moderate |
23,53 |
17,36 |
21,88 |
20,92 |
|
High |
39,87 |
40,50 |
34,38 |
39,54 |
|
Total |
100 |
100 |
100 |
100 |
DISCUSIÓN
There are various factors that contribute to the quality
of life of health sciences university students, among
them, eating patterns stand out, which added to the
practice of regular PA determine their nutritional status,
which at the same time is indirectly related to the stress
level of the individual since low physical activity is
associated with its increase. Therefore, it is postulated
that an imbalance between these components will be
reected in the decrease or increase of the student's
BMI and implies a greater risk of disease20. In this
regard, in a study carried out by Urbanetto et al. In
nursing students, a weight increase was evidenced in
52.60%, as well as high-stress levels in 29.50% and very
high in 36.80%. Furthermore, overweight and obesity
were associated with physical inactivity, increased
frequency of meals in stressful situations, and
unhealthy food intake(21) .
Nutritional habits, such as eating fast food, sweets, soft
drinks, and, in some cases, alcohol, are related to an
increase in BMI. In the present work, the students with
increased BMI indicated a higher consumption of soft
drinks, meat, and alcohol; as well as a lower intake of
legumes. In relation to the nutritional status according
to eating habits, according to an investigation carried
out by Reyes et al., Malnutrition due to excess or
deciency is more frequent in university students with
inadequate eating habits(22) .
Thus, Becerra-Bulla et al., When evaluating the
relationship between eating habits and changes in the
nutritional status of medical students, whose BMI
showed an increasing trend while the students passed
through the race, found a high consumption of dairy
products , meats, and fruit; regular intake of vegetables,
packaged foods and fried foods; and occasional fast
food and soda(23) . Torres-Mallma et al., After comparing
the consumption of fast food and soft drinks, among
first and sixth year medical students, found an increase
in their consumption in the last group, a signicant
difference was also found in terms of alcohol intake,
being more frequent in older students(14) . In contrast to
previous studies, at present, no signicant difference
was shown for pastry, candy, vegetables, or fast food.
The regular eating pattern includes breakfast, lunch,
and dinner; Eliminating one of these main meals in the
long term has negative health effects(24) .
According to the literature, the importance of breakfast
is that it provides the greatest amount of energy for
daily activities; therefore, its omission negatively affects
the performance and health of the student. Likewise, it
has been shown that eating a breakfast rich in ber and
fruits reduces the risk of overweight and reduces the
appearance of chronic non-communicable diseases(20) .
Torres-Mallma et al. found, in Peruvian medical
students, that 51.3% of the participants always ate
breakfast, which they attributed to factors such as class
hours, study ov e rl o ad, sl e ep qua l it y, and
socioeconomic aspects(14) . In a cohort conducted by
Wennberg et al., It was found that irregular food intake,
mainly poor breakfast consumption during
adolescence, predicted the appearance of metabolic
syndrome in adulthood(18) .
In contrast, in the present investigation, it was found
that young people consume breakfast daily by 95.75%.
Despite this, it is still necessary to reinforce education in
habits and food consumption that must be carried out
as a plan of nutritional programs included in university
education.
On the other hand, stress has been divided into positive
or "eustress" and negative or "distress". Especially, the
latter, if it persists and becomes chronic, keeps the body
in constant overstimulation, which predisposes to the
development of various pathologies(25) . In the current
study, the levels of distress according to the BMI showed
a difference close to signicance, with the lowest levels
in obese students. In this regard, in a study carried out
by Jalca-Ávila et al., In which the role of stress as a trigger
for the increase in BMI in Clinical Laboratory students
was evaluated, despite not nding an association with
obesity, it was observed between being overweight
and low and medium stress levels(26) .
Various factors related to the increase in BMI in medical
students were studied. It was found that PA classied as
low, according to the IPAQ questionnaire, represents a
sedentary lifestyle. It is pointed out that the decrease in
physical activity due to sedentary lifestyle is a risk factor
for increasing overweight and obesity(27) , but it was not corroborated in the present study; however, the
percentage of sedentary lifestyle was 39.54%, being
higher in the population with a high BMI. Santillán et al.
measured the level of PA in medical and business
administration students and found that the former are
more sedentary (66%)(28) . Unlike the present work,
Choque et al. In 200 rst-year medical students they
only found a 23% prevalence of sedentary lifestyle, but
they had a lower frequency of being overweight 17%
and obesity 1%(29) .
The findings of this research can be extrapolated to
medical students with characteristics similar to those
described. The intervention of factors such as
geographic area, cultural differences, socioeconomic
condition, and academic requirement must be taken
into account.
In addition, it is recommended to establish a program of
nutritional guidance, anti-stress therapy, and physical
activity throughout the race to reduce the increase in
BMI. It is also suggested to carry out similar
investigations taking into account the control of other variables such as age, gender, and year of study,
comparing the groups; study the effect of the COVID-19
pandemic on stress level, PA, BMI, and eating behaviors
in medical students; as well as to follow up the students
by applying the questionnaires immediately after
completing the evaluations.
The COVID-19 pandemic limited the development of
the research, as well as the call for the target sample; in
addition, it prevented the performance of subsequent
anthropometric controls.
CONCLUSIONS
The rise in BMI in medical students was associated with inappropriate eating habits such as higher intake of alcoholic beverages, meats, soft drinks, and lower consumption of legumes, as well as a higher frequency of occasional breakfast consumption. Low levels of distress and physical activity were more frequent in obese patients, although without signicant association.
Authorship contributions: The authors participated in
the genesis of the idea, project design, data collection
and interpretation, results analysis and manuscript
preparation of this research work.
Funding sources: The study was partially funded by the
National University of Trujillo in collaboration with the
authors.
Conflicts of interest: The authors express that there are
no conicts of interest when writing the manuscript.
Received: August 28, 2021
Approved: : December 14, 2021
Correspondence: Claudia Cecilia Aguilar Ydiáquez
Address: Av. Salaverry 505, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, Perú
Telephone number: 944673888
E-mail: caguilary@unitru.edu.pe