REVIEW ARTICLE
REVISTA DE LA FACULTAD DE MEDICINA HUMANA 2024 - Universidad Ricardo Palma
1 Universidad de Manizales, Faculty of Health Sciences, Medicine Program.
2 Fundación Universitaria Autónoma de las Américas, Faculty of Health Sciences, Medicine
Program.
a Psychologist. PhD, Mg.
b Medical Geneticist.
c General practitioner.
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Suicide and suicidal behaviors (SC) are a complex and multidetermined phenomenon in
which different genetic, environmental and individual factors interact. The objective of this study was
to carry out a review of the genetic factors associated with suicidal behavior described in the
literature of the last 10 years.
Methods: A search was made of all available articles, both review articles, case reports and
management guidelines under the descriptors in health sciences (DeCS) Suicidal behavior, suicide,
depression, exome, genetic markers, genetic variation, human genome, serotonin, norepinephrine,
dopamine, computational biology in the databases of Google scholar, LILACS, PubMed and ClinicalKe,
official websites such as those of the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Ministry of Health and
Social Protection of Colombia were consulted.
Development: Genetic studies of CS have been trying for decades to find the "suicide gene", in
order to prematurely identify those people with a higher risk of making suicide attempts and prevent
them from becoming victims; however, these studies failed to find a gene or group of genes that
differentiated between suicidal and nonsuicidal subjects. This type of technology gave rise to
genome-wide association studies (GWAS), with which some authors wanted to demonstrate the differences in
the genome of patients with suicidal ideas.
Conclusions: Knowledge of the genetic factors involved may lead to the possibility of identifying
individuals with a higher risk of developing suicidal behavior, thus having better tools and receiving a
more mechanistic vision to explore the underlying intermolecular network and prevent deaths from it.
cause.
Keywords: Behavior, suicide, depression, genetic markers, genetic variation, serotonin. (Source:
MeSH).
RESUMEN
Introducción: El suicidio y las conductas suicidas (CS) son un fenómeno complejo y
multideterminado en el que interactúan diferentes factores genéticos, ambientales e individuales. El
objetivo de este estudio fue realizar una revisión de los factores genéticos asociados a la conducta
suicida descritos en la literatura de los últimos 10 años.
Métodos: Se realizó una búsqueda de todos los artículos disponibles tanto artículos de revisión,
como reportes de caso y guías de manejo bajo los descriptores en ciencias de la salud (DeCS) Conducta
suicida, suicidio, depresión, exoma, marcadores genéticos, variación genética, genoma humano,
serotonina, norepinefrina, dopamina, biología computacional en las bases de Google scholar, LILACS,
PubMed y ClinicalKe, se consultaron sitios web oficiales como los de Organización Mundial de la Salud
(OMS) y Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social de Colombia.
Desarrollo: Los estudios genéticos de las CS, llevan décadas intentando encontrar el “gen del
suicidio”, con el fin de identificar de manera prematura aquellas personas con mayor riesgo de realizar
intentos suicidas y prevenir que se conviertan en víctimas; sin embargo, estos estudios fallaron en
encontrar un gen o grupo de éstos que diferenciara entre sujetos suicidas y no suicidas. A este tipo de
tecnología surgieron los estudios de asociación del genoma completo (GWAS), con los cuales algunos
autores quisieron demostrar las diferencias del genoma de pacientes con ideas suicidas.
Conclusiones: El conocimiento de los factores genéticos implicados puede llevar a que sea posible
identificar los individuos con mayor riesgo de desarrollar comportamiento suicida, de esta forma tener
mejores herramientas y recibir una visión más mecanicista para explorar la red intermolecular subyacente
y prevenir las muertes por esta causa.
Palabras clave: Conducta, suicidio, depresión, marcadores genéticos, variación genética,
serotonina, dopamina, norepinefrina. (Fuente:
DeCS-BIREME)
Introduction
Emile Durkheim defines suicide as “any case of death resulting directly or indirectly from a positive or
negative act carried out by the victim herself, knowing that this result would ensue”; that is, the
victim at the moment of performing the act that ends her life, knows with certainty what the outcome
will be (1). Suicide attempts are acts of self-harm with the intent to die,
and completed suicide is the result of ending one's own life(2, 3, 4).
The World Health Organization (WHO) has estimated that for every death by suicide, approximately 20
people attempt suicide, with around 703,000 people taking their own lives and many more attempting to do
so. All these cases are tragedies that affect families, communities, and countries and have lasting
effects on the victims’ relatives(5).
Suicide is a global health problem, ranking as the third leading cause of death among individuals aged
15 to 19 years(6). In the region, Colombia ranks third in suicide death
rates, following Cuba and Brazil. Between 2005 and 2016, the age-adjusted mortality rate for
self-inflicted injuries varied between 4.42 to 5.2 per 100,000 inhabitants(7). As in the rest of the world, suicide in Colombia is more common among
men, with an approximate ratio of 4:1(8, 9).
Suicide or suicidal behavior (SB) is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon influenced by various genetic
and environmental factors that promote these behaviors(10, 11). Risk factors for suicidal behavior include personal factors such as
gender, age, history of psychopathology; family factors, lack of support networks, exclusion, substance
abuse, and low socioeconomic conditions, among others(12). Some authors
have demonstrated that different psychiatric disorders, especially major depressive disorder (MDD),
increase the risk of suicidal behaviors, including suicide, relating the propensity of individuals with
MDD not only to mood disturbances (hopelessness or catastrophizing) but also to alterations in
neurotransmitters, inflammatory mediators, and brain neurotrophic factors present in both individuals
with MDD and those with suicidal behaviors(13, 14, 15). For example, decreased serotonin transmission leads to depressive
states, causing suicidal behavior due to the emergence of a depressed mood(16). Other associated disorders include bipolar affective disorder, anxiety
disorders, schizophrenia, and some personality and behavioral disorders(17).
Authors like Brent et al.(15) indicate that the heritability of suicide has
been estimated to range from 30% to 50%, independent of the inheritance of mental disorders; and in
suicide attempts, from 17% to 45%. This explains why, recently, risk factors associated with suicidal
behaviors have been investigated(16).
The study of candidate genes was based on hypothesizing about the neurotransmitters or pathways altered
in people with SB. Genes involved in these functions were postulated, and searches for variations were
conducted(17). Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have been relevant in
analyzing complex phenotypes such as SB, consisting of obtaining the complete genome sequence and
finding differences between the genomes of individuals with a suicidal tendency(18).
Epigenetics has emerged as the field of knowledge responsible for elucidating the complex mechanisms
through which the environment affects the genome and its expression(19).
These studies can identify genetic determinants that serve as biomarkers in the genomes of individuals
predisposed to develop SB. Therefore, the objective of the present study is to review the genetic
factors associated with suicidal behavior described in the literature over the past ten years.
Methods
A search was conducted for all available articles from the last 10 years, including review articles,
case reports, and management guidelines, using the Health Sciences Descriptors (DeCS): suicidal
behavior, suicide, depression, exome, genetic markers, genetic variation, human genome, serotonin,
norepinephrine, computational biology, in the databases Google Scholar, LILACS, PubMed, and ClinicalKey.
Official websites such as those of the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Ministry of Health and
Social Protection of Colombia were also consulted.
Development
Serotonin
The serotonergic system has been the most studied in cases of suicide and suicidal behavior. Since the
1970s, candidate genes related to serotonin synthesis pathways, transporters, receptors, and metabolism
have been studied(20). Mirkovic et al. have shown variants in the genes for
tryptophan hydroxylase 1 and 2, serotonin receptors 1A, 1B, 2A, and the SLC6A4 transporter(16). They propose that variations in tryptophan hydroxylase, the
rate-limiting enzyme in serotonin production, encoded by the TPH1 and TPH2 genes, specifically the
TPH1-RS 1800532 variant, are associated with suicidal behaviors, based on the meta-analysis results by
Clayden et al.(20) which found a statistically significant relationship
between the A allele of the TPH1-rs1800532 variant and suicidal behaviors (OR 1.22 [CI 1.05-1.41] p=
0.007). Another consistent candidate is the serotonin transporter (5-HTT), a molecule involved in
serotonergic signaling pathways encoded by the SLC6A4 gene. A statistically significant relationship (OR
1.13 [CI 1.05-1.21] p= 0.001) was also found between the short variant of the 85-HTTSPR gene and suicide
attempts, but not with completed suicide, supporting the hypothesis that the inefficiency of the short
variant to generate the transporter affects serotonin function, leading to the development of depressive
spectrum disorders and a higher risk of suicide(18). Alterations in other
genes related to the serotonergic system have shown contradictory evidence regarding their role in the
occurrence of SB(21).
Dopamine/Norepinephrine
The monoamine system, represented by pathways related to pleasure, emotional state, and response to
external threats, has been the subject of studies involving candidate genes and the genes encoding
dopaminergic and adrenergic receptors, catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) genes, and monoamine oxidase
genes(22). Regarding COMT, an enzyme involved in the metabolism of these
neurotransmitters, the single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) Val158Met has been associated with SB in
studies such as that by Pivac et al.(22). However, there is contradictory
evidence. Calati et al.(23) and more recently González-Castro et
al.(24) concluded that the Val158Met rs4680 variant was not related to SB.
However, they performed a subgroup analysis by ethnicity and gender and found a possible association
between the Val158 polymorphism and SB in male patients and Asian individuals.
Lung et al.(25) have evidenced that the MAOA-uVNRT variant (monoamine
oxidase enzyme) was associated with SB in men with major depressive disorder; however, Buttenschøn et
al.(26) did not find an association between this variant and SB. Hung et
al.(27) did not find differences after studying the allelic distribution of
the MAOA-uVNRT variant. Mirkovic et al.(16) concluded that the genotype may
not exert a direct influence on SB, but as mentioned with serotonergic system genes, it may contribute
to the expression of a complex phenomenon such as suicidal behaviors.
Neurotrophic Factors System
Common variants include genes related to serotonin and variants within the BDNF gene. A study found that
individuals carrying the short allele (one or two copies) of the serotonin transporter gene had more
depressive symptoms and were more likely to have a major depressive disorder diagnosis when exposed to
life traumas or stress compared to individuals homozygous for the long allele(27). These genes have been associated with other psychiatric symptoms and
disorders, including depressive disorder and ADHD(28).
Mirkovic et al.(16) indicate that different postmortem studies have
evidenced the potential role of alterations in the brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF). They note
that the Val66Met (rs6265) polymorphism of BDNF has been associated with suicidal behaviors in patients
of different ethnic groups and with various psychiatric disorders. However, the meta-analysis by Zai et
al.(28), which used data from 12 studies with 3,352 people, reported 1,202
with a history of suicidal behavior; it failed to demonstrate a direct association between Met carriers
of the Val66Met polymorphism and completed suicides but was present in those patients with a history of
other SB.
GABAergic System
A complex interaction has been identified between the T allele rs3219151 of the GABRA6 gene and recent
life stress in multiple phenotypes associated with suicidal behavior, leading to a significant suicide
risk. The effect of the T allele of the mentioned gene, in interaction with recent negative life events:
depression, anxiety, and suicide risk, was investigated in a sample of 2,283 Europeans. They found that
in any investigated phenotype, this allele likely plays a role in mediating the effects of recent stress
on the emergence of suicidal behaviors. However, after exposure to recent negative events, the presence
of the GABRA6 rs3219151T allele increased the risk of depression (BSI-DEP) and anxiety (BSI-ANX)(29).
Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS)
Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) allow for an exploration of genetic variants associated with
various disorders by performing an association of the entire genome and applying analyses where
statistical significance is defined by p< 5.0 x 10-8. However, the results have not been
consistent or reproducible among different studies, and clear pathophysiological pathways have not
been defined. This lack of consistency can be explained by heterogeneity in sample selection;
another factor has been variations in genomes among different ethnicities and the low number of
patients in which some studies have been conducted30. This has not prevented different authors from
conducting studies whose results have pointed out some variants related to SB.
The meta-analysis by González-Castro et al.(24) included 21 studies
that used the GWAS technique, performing a genetic origin (GO) analysis to evaluate the biological
plausibility of the found polymorphisms. It reported that biological processes with statistically
significant variations included the pathway of glucose import regulation in response to insulin (p=
0.02), associated with psychiatric disorders and suicidal behaviors. Finally, the regulation pathway
of cardiomyocyte contraction (p= 0.04), associated with impulse transmission in the central nervous
system and whose alterations have been linked to disorders such as autism spectrum disorders(25, 26). The largest GWAS conducted, to our
knowledge, analyzed patients with psychiatric disorders (major depressive disorder, bipolar
disorder, and schizophrenia) and suicide attempts, comparing them to patients with the same
disorders without suicide attempts, finding a single polymorphism with statistical significance in a
non-coding RNA variant and interestingly through association with a polygenic risk score for
depression. They found that the score was higher in patients with suicide attempts; revealing once
again the interaction between depression and SB; and how the presence of depressive symptoms in
patients with other psychiatric disorders or the presence of their genes can help identify those at
higher risk(27).
Genes and Environment in Suicidal Behaviors
Epigenetics allows the study of the relationships between the environment and the regulation of gene
expression through heritable changes that do not affect the nucleotide sequence of the
genome(28) and has emerged in this case as a tool to explain the gaps
that have been evidenced between the heritability of SB and the influence of the environment and
stressors(29).
The relationships between genes and the environment were included in the scientific community's
debate on psychiatric diseases, focusing on the relationships between a candidate polymorphism and
environmental stressors in depression(39).
Subsequently, epigenetic studies began to gain more relevance compared to candidate gene studies,
which had found genes related to monoamines such as serotonin, dopamine, and even epinephrine.
However, in the late 2000s, the suppression of the SAT-1 enzyme in the dorsolateral area of the
prefrontal cortex of suicide victims' brains was identified, attracting even more attention from
multiple researchers(40).
Discussion
Genetic studies of suicidal behaviors emerged from the familial clustering of the phenomenon, and
for decades, researchers have sought to find the "suicide gene" to identify those at higher risk of
suicide attempts early and prevent suicides(41).
The emergence of the possibility of identifying suicide genes and their variations in peripheral
blood mononuclear cells would allow for their identification and the implementation of specific
preventive measures(42). However, the initial methodology to find these
genes was through candidate gene studies, which failed to identify a gene or group of genes that
distinguished between suicidal and non-suicidal individuals. Among their limitations were the
theoretical selection bias applied when postulating the genes to investigate, different psychiatric
diagnoses in the studied patients, ethnic variations, and underrepresented populations(43).
The optimization of sequencing techniques and increased accessibility to this technology led to
genome-wide association studies (GWAS), through which some authors developed studies to demonstrate
the differences in the genome of patients experiencing suicidal ideation during antidepressant
treatment(44, 45), with inconsistent results.
Subsequently, studies were proposed in individuals with different psychiatric disorders, and in the
meta-analysis by González-Castro et al.(24), it was evidenced that
despite the relationship with pathways that interfere with central nervous system activities, none
of the genetic origins in the study coincided with previously postulated genes. The review authors
assert that more studies with better designs are needed to allow comparison and analysis of genome
association studies with suicidal behaviors. In general, the complex relationships between different
genetic factors and the heterogeneity of genes among populations add significant complexity to
genetic studies of SB, and this could explain the failed attempts of GWAS studies to identify the
trigger of SB(25).
A final element playing a determining role in the appearance of SB is the influence of environmental
factors, which can be early, especially during neurodevelopment, and late or proximal, which can be
identified as immediate triggers of suicidal acts(26).
Conclusions
Suicidal behaviors represent a public health problem, particularly due to their high burden as a
significant cause of death among young people and older adults(27).
Although 90% of people who die by suicide have been diagnosed with psychiatric disorders that have a
heritable component, suicidal behaviors have not yet been independently genetically associated with
psychiatric disorders. Therefore, understanding the genetic factors involved could eventually make
it possible to identify individuals at higher risk of developing some form of suicidal behavior and
prevent deaths from this cause(27). For now, the multiplicity of
factors involved in the appearance of suicidal behaviors demonstrates that addressing the problem
must be interdisciplinary, with a fundamental component being community-based rehabilitation to
reduce the phenomenon of "social pain" present in the testimonies of people with suicidal behaviors,
derived from societal exclusion(28). Efforts from different action
groups are needed to strengthen mental health education, improve the social environment in which
everyone, especially patients with mental illnesses, operates; and finally, research on suicidal
behaviors should be maintained, encouraged, and disseminated. A greater understanding of the
phenomenon is needed to have better tools and receive a more mechanistic view to explore the
underlying intermolecular network, acting as a delicate interface to receive environmental inputs
vulnerable to the magnitude of external adversities with an increasing risk of a suicidal phenotype.
With this, it will be more useful to design effective strategies for early behavior assessment and
suicide attempt prevention.
Authorship contributions:
The authors participated in the conceptualization, research, methodology, resources, and
drafting of the original manuscript.
Financing:
Self-funded.
Declaration of conflict of interest:
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Recevied:
January 1, 2024
Approved:
April 23, 2024
Correspondence author:
María Manuela Rodríguez-Gutiérrez
Address:
Av. de las Américas #98-56, Pereira, Risaralda
Phone:
+5763200303
E-mail:
maria.rodriguezg@uam.edu.co
Article published by the Journal of the faculty of Human Medicine of the Ricardo Palma University. It is an open access article, distributed under the terms of the Creatvie Commons license: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), that allows non-commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided that the original work is duly cited. For commercial use, please contact revista.medicina@urp.edu.pe.